A married man recently caused a family feud after admitting the real reason his wife never bonded with her nephew, against his sister-in-law’s wishes. Here’s what the husband had to say.
The Wife’s Father Was Killed
The man began, “When my wife was 17, she and her dad got into a traumatic accident that ended up fatally injuring her father and severely injuring her. I can’t share everything, but it ended up causing her to go into a coma for a few years.”
She Was Traumatized
Although the man’s wife eventually healed from her physical injuries, the couple continued to work on her mental recovery, as the trauma was still very difficult for her to deal with.
She found it hard to talk about her father or look at photos, and remembering him at all was extremely painful.
The Sister Had a Son
The wife had a sister, Regina, and a brother, Calvin. Two years after the wife woke up from her coma, Regina had a son and decided to name him James after her deceased father.
In their country, the father-in-law had a unique and unusual name, and James was the only other person they knew with that name.
The Whole Family Were Against It
The man, his mother-in-law, Regina’s in-laws, Calvin, and Regina’s husband, Will, tried to persuade the sister to change the baby’s name, fearing it wouldn’t end well.
Regina ignored their concerns for her sister’s mental well-being and went ahead with the name anyway.
His Wife Struggled With The Name
As the family had predicted, the name choice didn’t go well. The wife was not as close to James as she was to her other nieces and nephews.
She did not treat him poorly, but she was more closed-off and did not spend as much time with him as she did with the others.
She Was More Distant With James
The husband explained, “She didn’t babysit James as often; she didn’t take him on fun stuff alone as often. She didn’t invite him to visit as much, and she won’t talk to him on bad days. However, she does that to Calvin too, because he looks so much like their father.”
His Mother Lied
When James turned 18, he could no longer ignore the difference in their relationship and decided to ask the man and his father for the real reason behind the distance.
His mother had previously told him that the emotional distance was because he was born soon after the accident, and they did not have the opportunity to bond.
They Told James Everything
The man and Will made the decision to disclose the truth to James, albeit in a softened manner. They explained that the challenges caused by his name were the root cause of the strained relationship with his aunt.
James was deeply shocked and horrified upon discovering the truth. This revelation triggered a major conflict at his family’s house, ultimately leading him to choose to stay with his grandmother.
His Sister-in-law Was Mad
Regina was upset with them, accusing her brother-in-law of “painting her as the villain.”
After discussing the situation with his friends, many thought he should not have told James the truth. They believed that the revelation only served to create more problems and tension within the family.
Was He Wrong?
However, the man stood by his decision, believing that James deserved to know the truth behind the emotional distance between him and his aunt throughout his life.
But, given his friends’ reaction, he sought validation online via the Reddit forum and asked users what they thought of his honesty.
People Responded
One person wondered, “Basically, he painted the boy’s mother as being uncaring of the aunt, and therefore, the aunt was too traumatized to get close to him. Yeah, YTA.”
Another said, “So it’s your sister-in-law’s fault for naming her son after her late father (an incredibly common thing, no matter how tragic the death) that your wife chose not to get close to her nephew? For 18 years, he had to watch his aunt choose his other cousins over him, and when he finally had the courage to ask why, his reaction to the answer was to abandon his mother. That doesn’t track.”
MORE FROM LOVED BY CURLS
Back in high school, a man’s classmate always made fun of others. One day, he unintentionally responded back at him. Now, at their high school reunion, his classmate demanded an apology. Did he apologize? Let’s find out.
A Man Kept Arguing With a Policeman Who Finally Asked Him For His Name and Then Found Out There Was a Warrant Out For His Arrest
A man recently told Reddit about the time he had to put up with a know-it-all at work until the co-worker got arrested.
An Army Clerk Got Revenge on His CO by Posting his Personnel Files Across the World and Ruining His Career
A man recently told Reddit about the time his dad got revenge on his horrible commanding officer in the army by messing with his career and ruining his chances for promotion. Here’s what he had to say:
A Man Dumped Several Tons of Sand in Front of a Building Site To Get Revenge on a Rude Builder
A man recently got revenge on a builder who kept using the man’s phone number in his ads. The man ended up costing the builder several hours of labor. Here’s what he had to say:
A Man Dumped Several Tons of Sand in Front of a Building Site To Get Revenge on a Rude Builder
This Couple Refused to Serve Alcohol at Their Wedding but Were Shocked When All of Their Friends Left Early
A man recently had an argument with his coworkers and his in-laws after he was coerced into having a dry wedding which caused most of the guests to leave early. Here is what he had to say.
*This post has been edited to include updated comments from forum users
Source: Reddit
