18 Movies That Were Completely Derailed By Their Own Plot Twists

A well-executed plot twist can make or break a movie, either leaving viewers in awe or disappointed. In this post, we’ll look at 18 films where a surprising twist ultimately proved damaging to the overall narrative.

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008)

Photo Credit: Lucasfilm Ltd.

Fans rejoiced at the return of Indiana Jones after a 19-year break. However, the controversial alien twist in the climax diverged significantly from the series’ archaeological adventure roots, introducing an unwelcome sci-fi element that left many feeling betrayed.

Now You See Me (2013)

Photo Credit: Summit Entertainment.

In a film centered around magic and deception, the final twist feels out of place with the rest of the plot. The abrupt revelation that Mark Ruffalo’s character masterminded everything undermines his prior character development and complicates the plot without adding substantial depth.

Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace (1999)

Star Wars_ Episode I – The Phantom Menace - Lucasfilm
Photo Credit: Lucasfilm.

George Lucas’s comeback to the Star Wars universe was highly anticipated. Unfortunately, the surprise revelation of midichlorians as the source of the Force disappointed fans, as it stripped away much of the mystique that had made the Force so captivating.

The Happening (2008)

Photo Credit: 20th Century Fox.

M. Night Shyamalan’s environmental horror film hinges on the mystery of mass suicides. The revelation that it’s due to plants emitting a toxin is met with laughter rather than fear, turning what would have been an interesting thriller into an unintended comedy.

The Snowman (2017)

Photo Credit: Universal Pictures.

Adapted from Jo Nesbø’s bestselling crime novel, the thriller suffers from a disjointed narrative. The plot twist concerning the identity of the serial killer falls flat due to the uninspiring character development and poor editing, failing to deliver the anticipated thrills of this genre of movie.

Planet of the Apes (2001)

Photo Credit: 20th Century Fox.

Tim Burton’s remake of Planet of the Apes concludes with a twist that leaves audiences more bewildered than amazed. The climactic revelation, where Earth has fallen under the dominion of apes, lacks the profound societal commentary that made the original 1968 film a classic.

The Village (2004)

The Village (2004) Touchstone Home Entertainment
Touchstone Home Entertainment.

M. Night Shyamalan’s The Village sets the stage with a captivating premise, where a 19th-century community is living in dread of mysterious creatures in the nearby woods. However, the twist uncovers a modern-day social experiment, undermining the carefully crafted tension and fear.

The Life of David Gale (2003)

Photo Credit: Universal Pictures.

The movie revolves around a man protesting the death penalty while on death row himself. The surprise ending unveils that he arranged his own murder to prove a point, straining credibility and diluting the film’s intended message.

Remember Me (2010)

Photo Credit: Underground Films.

Starring Robert Pattinson, this drama attempts to evoke a surprising emotional response with a last-minute reveal that links the story to the 9/11 attacks. However, this late plot twist feels forced and manipulative, leaving a bitter aftertaste instead of the intended moving response.

Hancock (2008)

Photo Credit: Columbia/TriStar.

This superhero film begins as an intriguing character study of a disgruntled, alcoholic superhero. However, it takes an unexpected and unwelcome turn midway through with the abrupt introduction of Greek mythology, which feels out of place and reduces the impact of the original setup.

The Number 23 (2007)

Photo Credit: New Line Cinema.

Jim Carrey’s venture into psychological thrillers was an intriguing choice. Still, the film’s twist revealing a fictional book’s dark influence on the main character only complicated the narrative, adding confusion instead of the intended depth and tension.

High Tension (2003)

Photo Credit: EuropaCorp.

The French horror film is notorious for its graphic violence and suspenseful plot. However, the twist ending, revealing it’s all been a character’s hallucination, raises more questions than answers.

Passengers (2016)

Passengers Village Roadshow Pictures _ Start Motion Pictures _ Original Film _ LStar Capital _ Wanda Pictures _ Company Films _ Columbia Pictures
Photo Credit: Columbia Pictures.

This sci-fi romance takes a controversial direction when Chris Pratt’s character, stranded alone on a spaceship, decides to awaken Jennifer Lawrence’s character, dooming her to a life with him. The movie’s attempts to frame this as romantic leaves many viewers feeling uncomfortable.

Sunshine (2007)

Sunshine - DNA Films_ Ingenious Film Partners
Photo Credit: Ingenious Film Partners.

Danny Boyle’s sci-fi thriller impresses audiences with breathtaking visuals and claustrophobic tension. But when the final act shifts into horror territory by bringing in a disfigured, half-supernatural villain, it feels at odds with the rest of the movie. It also undercuts the thoughtful, existential quality set up in the first two acts.

Law Abiding Citizen (2009)

Photo Credit: Overture Films.

At first, the movie paints an engaging picture of a man who takes the law into his own hands after a legal loophole releases his family’s killers from jail. The final twist, which reveals he’s become a fully-fledged terrorist, feels over-the-top and betrays the narrative of the film so far.

The Forgotten (2004)

Photo Credit: Columbia Pictures.

This film follows the story of a woman whose son disappears, and no one remembers who he is. At first a psychological thriller about gaslighting and memory, the sudden plot twist revealing an alien conspiracy is a massive letdown, taking away from what could have been a captivating movie about loss and sanity.

The Box (2009)

Photo Credit: Warner Bros.

Based on Richard Matheson’s short story called “Button, Button,” the movie adds to the original tale. It spins off in another direction, with an elaborate plot involving aliens and morality. The twist brings more confusion to the movie than it does clarity and downgrades the intriguing original premise.

Secret Window (2004)

Photo Credit: Columbia Pictures.

The psychological horror, based on Stephen King’s novella, begins with a curious mystery about a writer accused of plagiarism. However, the twist that the prosecutor is the writer’s alternating personality is a cliche that feels unoriginal, deflating the suspense and flattening the climax into a bore.

READ MORE – 18 MOVIE MYSTERIES THAT STILL HAVE NO EXPLANATION

American Psycho (2000) - Lionsgate Films
Photo Credit: Lionsgate Films.

Movie makers often leave certain plot points ambiguous to spark discussions and theories among the audience. While some mysteries are later resolved in sequels or by the filmmakers themselves, others remain unexplained. Here are 18 movie mysteries that still leave us scratching our heads

18 MOVIE MYSTERIES THAT STILL HAVE NO EXPLANATION

20 MOVIES THAT WERE SO GOOD WE WISH WE COULD WATCH THEM AGAIN FOR THE FIRST TIME

Interstellar - Paramount Pictures
Photo Credit: Paramount Pictures.

Some movies are so great that we wish we could watch them again for the very first time. Someone recently asked the users of Reddit which movies they would choose, and we’ve listed the top 20 answers below.

20 MOVIES THAT WERE SO GOOD WE WISH WE COULD WATCH THEM AGAIN FOR THE FIRST TIME

THE 38 MOST AWESOME ‘BAD GUYS’ IN MOVIE HISTORY

T-1000
Photo Credit: StudioCanal.

They’re the ones we love to hate, the characters that make our blood boil, and keep us on the edge of our seats. These are the 38 best movie villains of all time.

THE 38 MOST AWESOME ‘BAD GUYS’ IN MOVIE HISTORY

18 OVERLOOKED MOVIES FROM THE 90S THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN BLOCKBUSTERS

Waterworld Universal Pictures
Photo Credit: Universal Pictures.

The 90s produced some of the most iconic movies in history, but some hidden gems were overshadowed by blockbusters. In this post, we’ll showcase the top 18 most underrated movies from the 90s that deserve more recognition, from indie favorites to forgotten cult classics.

18 OVERLOOKED MOVIES FROM THE 90S THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN BLOCKBUSTERS

25 MOVIE COUPLES WHO HAD ZERO CHEMISTRY

Star Wars – Anakin _ Padme Lucasfilm Productions
Photo Credit: Lucasfilm Productions.

Romantic movies can be a great way to escape into a world of love and passion, but sometimes, the chemistry between the lead actors just doesn’t seem to exist. A recent internet poll asked, “What movies have the worst chemistry?”:

25 MOVIE COUPLES WHO HAD ZERO CHEMISTRY